Your Marketing Team Is Not a Vending Machine

The strange habit businesses have of treating marketing as something they can simply press a button on.

There is a peculiar arrangement in many businesses whereby marketing becomes the department everybody remembers when they want something. There is a peculiar arrangement in many businesses whereby marketing becomes the department everybody remembers when they want something. There is a peculiar arrangement in many businesses whereby marketing becomes the department everybody remembers when they want something. There is a peculiar arrangement in many businesses whereby marketing becomes the department everybody remembers when they want something. There is a peculiar arrangement in many businesses whereby marketing becomes the department everybody remembers when they want something.

The requests arrive with the cheerful confidence of people ordering from a menu. Marketing, it seems, is simply the machine on the other side of the wall that produces things when sufficiently shaken. The requests arrive with the cheerful confidence of people ordering from a menu. Marketing, it seems, is simply the machine on the other side of the wall that produces things when sufficiently shaken.

The requests arrive with the cheerful confidence of people ordering from a menu. Marketing, it seems, is simply the machine on the other side of the wall that produces things when sufficiently shaken.

The requests arrive with the cheerful confidence of people ordering from a menu. Marketing, it seems, is simply the machine on the other side of the wall that produces things when sufficiently shaken.The requests arrive with the cheerful confidence of people ordering from a menu. Marketing, it seems, is simply the machine on the other side of the wall that produces things when sufficiently shaken.

A video by Friday.

A website updated “quickly”.

A campaign, preferably launched tomorrow.

The requests arrive with the cheerful confidence of people ordering from a menu. Marketing, it seems, is simply the machine on the other side of the wall that produces things when sufficiently shaken.

It is an unfortunate way to run a marketing department.

The problem is not that these requests are unreasonable. Quite often, they are perfectly reasonable. The problem is that the marketing team is rarely invited into the conversation that happens before the request.

Why are we doing this?

Who are we trying to reach?

What are we trying to change?

What problem are we solving?

What does success look like?

Instead, marketing is frequently handed the final instruction without ever being allowed to influence the decision that produced it.

That distinction matters.

A designer can produce the requested artwork. A copywriter can write the requested words. A social media manager can publish the requested post.

But none of those activities necessarily constitute marketing.

They are outputs.

Marketing is the thinking that comes before them.

This is where many organisations quietly go wrong. They measure activity because activity is easy to see. A campaign went live. Six posts were published. A brochure was printed. An email was sent.

Everyone was busy.

Nobody knows whether any of it mattered.

The better businesses understand that marketing should be involved much earlier. Not because marketers need to be invited to every meeting simply to feel important, but because the discipline exists to answer questions that other departments are not necessarily equipped to answer.

Sales knows how to sell.

Operations knows how to deliver.

Finance knows what things cost.

Marketing should know why someone might care.

That means marketing has to become comfortable asking awkward questions.

Do we actually need this campaign?

Is this the right audience?

Why are we saying this?

What evidence do we have that anyone wants it?

And occasionally, the most valuable answer a marketer can give is:

No.

No, we don’t need another social post.

No, changing the colour isn’t the solution.

No, increasing the budget won’t fix the positioning.

No, the problem isn’t reach.

No, we shouldn’t launch yet.

That is not marketing being difficult.

That is marketing doing its job.

The strongest marketing teams are not factories for content. They are counsel.

They provide judgement before execution, restraint before noise, and clarity before activity.

Perhaps the next time someone walks into the marketing department with a brief, the first question shouldn’t be:

“When do you need it?”

It should be:

“What are we trying to achieve?”

That single question might save you an awful lot of posters.

From the archive